The lighthouse is located on shore at Avery Point, at the east side of the Thames River entrance in Groton, Connecticut. Avery Point was originally named for an early settler in the area named Captain James Avery. For a long time, the seventy-three-acre site served as the huge estate of a wealthy industrialist named Morton F. Plant. Plant died in 1918, and in 1942 the land was sold to the State of Connecticut, which in turn handed it over to the Coast Guard. From 1942 to 1967, it was the site of the United States Coast Guard Training Center.
In 1969, the land was returned to the State of Connecticut at no cost, and it became part of the University of Connecticut at Avery Point campus. Given the designation of Building #41 by the university, the former lighthouse building has been used as a physics laboratory and an air sampling station.
By the late 1990s, the condition of the tower had deteriorated to the point where it was considered unsafe. Word got out to local residents, and APLS was formed to save the lighthouse. A petition drive gathered the signatures of over 19,000 people demanding the restoration and relighting of Avery Point Lighthouse. The University of Connecticut signed an agreement allowing APLS to work on the lighthouse. Funding came from a variety of sources, including the sale of over 2,000 personalized bricks to individual donors, to be part of a landscaped walkway around the base of the tower. Avery Point Lighthouse was added to the National Register of Historic Places in 2002.
The tower’s concrete blocks were found to be crumbling, the result of high sand content, and were the first things to be replaced. The original lantern was lifted by crane and transported to West Mystic Wooden Boat Building Company, which is owned by a former lighthouse keeper and a then English professor at the University of Connecticut. The company graciously donated its time and materials for the restoration project. The old wooden lantern was used as a template for the construction of the new replica lantern, which was lowered into place on September 30, 2005 as about fifty cheering spectators looked on.
Extensive restoration and refurbishing continued during 2004 and 2005 under the auspices of APLS. Thirty-two marble balusters originally imported from Italy were removed, cleaned and repaired by masons, and then put back into place. Meanwhile, the interior had to be completely gutted and cleaned, with new electrical wiring, custom-made doors and windows, and fresh paint and other structural and cosmetic work applied. Local craftspeople and merchants donated many of the goods and services necessary to make the restoration complete.
After six years of work and the expenditure of $500,000, a ceremony to relight the restored Avery Point Lighthouse was held on October 15th, 2006. The main speakers at the event were Fran Mainella, National Parks Service Director, Philip Austin, President of the University of Connecticut, and Rob Simmons, U. S. Congressman. The actual relighting was performed by three individuals representing the “Past, Present, and Future.” Ken Black, who was stationed at Avery Point when it was the Coast Guard Training Station represented the “Past.” Fran Mainella represented the “Present,” and Lexis Foster, the twelve-year-old granddaughter of APLS Co-Chairman Ron Foster represented the “Future.”