The site for Hooper Island Lighthouse was roughly eleven miles down the bay from Cove Point, and when Point No Point would be completed an additional nine miles down the bay from Hooper Island, but on the opposite side of the shipping channel, the stretch between Cove Point and Smith Point lights would be adequately marked.
Congress provided the necessary funds for Hooper Island Lighthouse in two $30,000 allotments made in 1898 and 1899. A $18,955 contract was awarded to Variety Iron Works of Cleveland for providing the metalwork, while Toomey Brothers of Connecticut was to be paid $29,000 for erecting the lighthouse. The Cleveland foundry was late delivering its work, forcing the cancellation of the contract with Toomey Brothers. The construction contract was thus re-advertised in June 1900, and once again Toomey Brothers provided the lowest bid. This time their bid was $31,300, over $2,000 more than their earlier one.
Hooper Island Lighthouse is one of only eleven in the U.S. that rests atop a caisson foundation sunk using the pneumatic process. In this procedure, a cast-iron cylinder is mounted atop a wooden caisson containing an airtight compartment. After this arrangement has been towed to the construction site, water is pumped out of the chamber. Construction workers then shovel or otherwise remove sand and sludge away from the edges of the caisson, and the heavy concrete and stone inside the cylinder causes the entire structure to sink into the bottom of the bay. The pneumatic process is far from simple. In the case of the construction of Point No Point Lighthouses, the caisson overturned and was pushed down the bay by a gale, but, fortunately, work went far more smoothly at Hooper Island.
Although Hooper Island Lighthouse was one of only four Chesapeake lighthouses erected during the twentieth century, it was still not quite modern enough to escape the necessity of human keepers and all of the expensive amenities and equipment required by them. A four-story tower, topped with a watchroom and lantern room, was thus built on the foundation to house the keepers and the station’s equipment. The foundation cylinder has a diameter of thirty-three feet, and as the tower’s diameter was only eighteen feet at its base, there was room for a covered gallery around the first level of the tower. A fourth-order Fresnel lens, manufactured in 1888 by F. Barbier & Company of Paris, was installed in the lantern room and exhibited for the first time on the night of June 1, 1902. A fog bell, manufactured by McShane of Baltimore in 1901, was mounted on the watchroom gallery, where it was alternately struck a single and double blow every twenty seconds during thick or foggy weather.
Hooper Island Lighthouse sits in eighteen feet of water about three miles west of Middle Hooper Island. The foundation extends eighteen feet above the high waterline, and the focal plane of the light is sixty-three feet. In 1904, the light’s characteristic was changed to fixed white punctuated by a flash at fifteen-second intervals. Hooper Island Lighthouse was electrified in 1936, and at this time a Cunningham diaphragm fog horn was installed and the light’s characteristic was changed to the repeating ten-second signature of a one-second flash, two-second eclipse, one-second flash, and six-second eclipse.
Hooper Island Lighthouse was fully automated on November 21, 1961, at which time the light characteristic was changed to a white flash every five seconds. The fog horn subsequently operated continuously from September 15 to June 1 of each year. When the Coast Guard crew was withdrawn from Hooper Island Lighthouse in 1961, Old Plantation Flats Lighthouse became the only staffed lighthouse on the eastern side of the Chesapeake.
When the Coast Guard called at the lighthouse during a regular visit on September 15, 1976, they discovered that the original fourth-order Fresnel lens had been stolen, necessitating the installation of a new solar-powered beacon.
Anchored in the center of the cellar level and extending upwards to the floor of the lantern room, is a hollow iron column with a diameter of thirteen inches. This column’s primary purpose was to bear the load of the upper floors, though it also likely comprised the free-fall zone for the counterweights used to strike the fog bell and rotate the lens.
The tower’s first level served as the station’s kitchen, and still has parts of an old cabinet that once contained a sink, which drew water upwards from the cistern in the cellar. The second, third, and fourth levels contained office, bedroom, and living space for the keepers. The second and third stories have three windows each, while five circular, porthole windows provide light for the fourth level. For the bottom four levels, the tower is lined with bricks whose faces were glazed white to provide a smooth finish.
While the floors in the bottom four floors were originally wood, the floors of the watchroom and lantern room consist of cast-iron plates featuring a diamond pattern. In the center of the watchroom is a curved ship’s ladder that provides access through a trapdoor to the lantern room. The original iron lantern pedestal is still in place here, and curved, diamond-shaped panes of glass are used in the circular lantern room.
In 2006, the lighthouse, deemed excess by the Coast Guard, was offered at no cost to eligible entities, including federal, state, and local agencies, non-profit corporations, and educational organizations. Dorchester County and the U.S. Lighthouse Society both submitted applications for the lighthouse, and in May 2009, the deed for the tower was given to the U.S. Lighthouse Society, who also shares responsibility for Thomas Point Shoal Lighthouse.
In February 2017, the federal government announced it was searching for a new steward to assume ownership of the lighthouse, as the U.S. Lighthouse Society was amenable to voluntary reversion or re-conveyance of the property. A Notice of Availability was released on May 19, 2021, and eligible organizations were given until July 19, 2021 to submit a letter of interest. On August 8, 2022, the General Services Administration opened an online auction for the lighthouse with a starting bid of $15,000. Five bidders participated in the auction, which closed on September 23, 2002, with a high bid of $192,000.
On December 27, 2023, the new owner of the lighthouse was revealed to be fifty-two-year-old Richard Cucé, when the court clerk for Dorchester County recorded the deed. Cucé seems to be the ideal owner of the rusty lighthouse as he owns Blastco, an industrial painting and sandblasting business in Eastern Pennsylvania that has painted everything form train cars to rollercoasters.
Cucé participated in the auction for American Shoal Lighthouse that went for $860,000 in earlier in 2022, well above his budget. Cucé plans to restore Hooper Island Lighthouse to its original look, with a brownish red foundation, a white tower, and a black tower. Plans for the lighthouse include using it as a site to monitor water quality and marine life. Cucé has established a Facebook page so the public can follow his progress.