In 1918, a cellar was dug out beneath the dwelling. Besides the lighthouse, the station also had an oil house, barn, a granary, and a well house.
Frank MacKinnon, seen in the top left of this photograph served as keeper until 1917, when he drowned while setting traps on May 12, the first day of the lobster season. The mishap that ended with Frank in the water occurred just offshore from Naufrage, but Frank didn't know how to swim. Frank and Sarah MacKinnon had one son, Neil, who was eight at the time of the accident. Young Neil was familiar with the operation of the light and instructed some gentlemen how to light it the night of his father's passing. It was Sarah MacKinnon, however, who assumed official responsibility for the lighthouse, and she kept the light until 1922, having married Gus Gallant in 1920.
A story passed down through the MacKinnon family tells of how one stormy night the mechanism that rotated the light at Shipwreck Point failed, but Sarah faithfully revolved the lens by hand all night. She later received a letter from a captain thanking her for her diligent attention to the light as he had been dependent on it that very night.
Peter MacKinnon became keeper in 1922 after Sarah MacKinnon Gallant, shown in this photograph with her husband Gus Gallant, resigned. The final keeper of the light was Hugh MacDonald, who retired in 1966, when the light was automated.
Rather than maintain the vacant dwelling that housed the light, a new concrete tower was constructed a short distance west of the 1913 lighthouse in 1967 by Schurman’s Limited. This octagonal tower, with a height of 13.4 metres (44 feet) went into service on September 27, 1967, and today exhibits a three-second flash followed by an eclipse of two seconds every five seconds. The 1913 lighthouse, minus its lantern, is privately owned and remains in its original location.
Keepers: Francis MacKinnon (1913 – 1917), Sarah MacKinnon Gallant (1917 – 1922), Peter J. MacKinnon (1922 – 1939), Daniel Leonard O’Henley (1939 – 1955), Hugh Boniface MacDonald (1955 – 1966).