In 1908, the Lighthouse Board requested funds for a new light to mark the port at Hilo:
Hilo is the second port of importance in the Hawaiian Islands. Upon completion of the new breakwater now under way, the importance of this port will be greatly increased. During the last fiscal year shipments to noncontiguous territories and exports to foreign countries from Hilo amounted approximately to $5,287,654; merchandise received from the United States to $1,720,269; 69 sail and steam vessels, representing a gross tonnage of 81,725, entered and cleared the port. The present small fixed red lens lantern light, located on the old and dilapidated government wharf at the foot of Waianuenue street, is entirely inadequate for the requirements of the growing trade of Hilo, and should be replaced by a more powerful light. It is recommended that a fourth-order flashing light be established at some point on the shore of Hilo Bay.
John Fitzgerald served as keeper of the light from 1904 to 1910, when Ferdinand Mosher, the harbor master, assumed responsibility for the light. The pay in 1910 for keeping the light was $25 per month.
A concrete tower topped by an acetylene flash was erected on Coconut Point in 1915, and the present thirty-four-foot pyramidal tower was erected in 1975. The signature of Coconut Point Light is flashing green.
Head Keepers: John Fitzgerald (1904 – 1910), Ferdinand Mosher (1910 – 1917).