In 1888, the Lighthouse Board provided the following information to Congress in its request for funds to construct a lighthouse at the mouth of the Cedar River.
Cedar River Point is situated at the mouth of Cedar River, about 30 miles north of Menominee, and 32 miles south of Escanaba, Mich., between which ports there are no light-houses. The mouth of Cedar River offers the best anchorage on the west coast of Green Bay, and is much frequented by vessels seeking shelter. It is directly opposite the passage called Death’s Door, through which nearly all vessels pass when bound from Lake Michigan to Escanaba and all ports in Green Bay. The Whale’s Back Reef is about half-way between Cedar River Point and the “Door,” and there is no light to mark this dangerous obstruction to navigation.
In 1890, a one-acre site near the west pier was acquired from Jesse Spaulding, president of the Spaulding Lumber Company, for the token sum of one dollar. Jesse Spaulding had purchased a mill at the mouth of the Cedar River around 1862, so he had a vested interest in improving navigation at the harbor. The first mill on the river commenced operation in 1854.
A two-story, six-room keeper’s dwelling was constructed on the one-acre lot using red brick for the basement and first story, and shingled framework for the upper story. A tight board fence lined the property on the south and west sides, with a picket fence running along the north and east sides. A brick cistern was built in the cellar, and a brick oil house, with a capacity of 300 gallons, was erected near the dwelling.
A pair of range lights was added to the east pier in time to be displayed for the opening of navigation in 1891. In 1902, the front light of this range was displayed from a lantern on the south corner of the tall, pyramidal lighthouse, while the companion rear light consisted of a lantern suspended from a post on the inner end of the east pier, 500 feet from the front light. A well was drilled to a depth of 120 feet in 1895, providing a plentiful supply of water for the station.
After short terms of service by four keepers, Gustavus Umberham took charge of the lighthouse in 1890. He remained at the station until 1901, when he swapped positions with Nelson Knudsen, who was serving as keeper of the lighthouse in Algoma, Wisconsin.
The tall, pyramidal lighthouse was relocated from the pier to a site seventeen feet north of the north side of the dwelling in February 1908, where it continued its role as a fixed white coastal light. At the same time, the range lights were moved from the east pier to the west pier. The new front range light consisted of a fixed red lens lantern displayed at a focal plane of twenty-one feet from an eight-inch-square post, while the rear light, also fixed red, was displayed from a similar post at a focal plane of twenty-six-and-a-half feet. A six-foot-square lantern house was located on the channel side of the rear post.
In 1922, the range lights and Cedar River Light were discontinued, and an unattended acetylene light was established atop a thirty-one-foot, steel, skeletal tower on August 9 of that year. The new tower stood on the outer end of the west pier, and its light had a characteristic of a white flash every three seconds.
The River and Harbor Acts of October 27, 1965 authorized the construction of Cedar River State Harbor near the entrance to the river. The harbor serves as a harbor of refuge and offers transient and seasonal slips with modern amenities. A flashing green light is now displayed from a post on the outer end of the west pier.
All that is left of the community that grew up to support the saw mill on Cedar River are two churches and a few residences along M-35. The faux lighthouse that is part of restaurant and the keeper’s dwelling, hidden in trees on the opposite side of the highway, are the only indications that a formal lighthouse once stood along the banks of the river.
Head Keepers: Clifford W. Sanderson (1889 – 1890), Ole Hansen (1890), Hans L.Hansen (1890), Jacob Young (1890), Gustavus Umberham (1890 – 1901), Nelson Knudsen (1901 – 1922).