Congress appropriated $7,640 in 1863 for repairing the pier at Kenosha and rebuilding the beacon light thereon. Though the Lighthouse Board directed the project to be quickly completed, a scarcity of lumber prevented work on the pier from starting until 1865. With the pier repaired, a wooden-frame tower with a height of thirty feet was erected on the pierhead in 1866. The fourth-order Fresnel lens from Kenosha Lighthouse was placed in the pierhead tower to serve as the main light at Kenosha while the old Kenosha Lighthouse was torn down and replaced with the present brick tower. At the opening of navigation in 1867, the fourth-order lens was back producing a flashing white light atop Kenosha Lighthouse, and a sixth-order lens had been installed in the pierhead tower to produce a fixed red light.
Over the years, the north pier was extended eastward into Lake Michigan on several occasions. The pierhead light was moved 320 eastward to the end of the extended pier in 1875, and 310 feet of elevated walkway was put in place to allow the keeper to reach the light when seas washed over the pier. In each of the years 1880, 1881, 1883, and 1884, the light was moved seaward by roughly 100 feet to track the work of extending the pier and a corresponding length of elevated walkway was built.
On November 20, 1891, the schooner Evaline ran into the pierhead lighthouse, damaging the watchroom and carrying away a closet and service table. In 1893 and 1894, a pierhead conduit, devised by Lighthouse Engineer M. B. Adams was installed at nine pierhead lights on Lake Michigan. A post lantern was installed seaward of the primary pierhead light to form range lights for entering the various harbors, and the two lights were linked by an enclosed wooden conduit, supported by trestles spaced sixteen feet apart, that allowed a lantern, resting on a small car, to be run to and from the outer light. The outer end of the conduit terminated at a box that had glass panes on three of its four sides. The length of the conduit at Kenosha was 104 feet, the shortest of the nine conduits.
The conduit and outer light at Kenosha were destroyed by a gale on November 1, 1899, but the outer light was restored just five days later on a temporary structure.
Starting on October 26, 1900 a fixed red lens-lantern was hung from a temporary post to mark the southeast end of the breakwater and form a range with the pierhead light. To protect the light, an eighteen-foot-long, v-shaped barrier was built on the exposed side of the breakwater used twelve-inch-square lumber. In 1906, an octagonal frame structure, surmounted by a lantern with a dome, replaced the breakwater post light.
The pierhead light also received a new structure in 1906 in the form of a metal tower topped by a fourth-order lantern. This tower was constructed of twelve circular sections with varying diameters to form a gently tapered lighthouse. On April 16, heavy seas created by a gale seriously damaged the funnel-style tower on the breakwater. The lake-facing side of the tower was crushed in and the opposite side was pushed out, leaving a large hole through the tower.
On May 24, 1906, the pierhead light was changed from a sixth-order, fixed red light to a fourth-order flashing white light with a period of fifteen seconds through the installation of the Fresnel lens from Kenosha Lighthouse, which was discontinued at the this time.
A fog signal was housed in a rectangular, pyramidal structure located just seaward of the cylindrical tower and connected to it by a covered passageway. The characteristic of the Kenosha pierhead fog signal had previously been a continuous blast, but on May 24, 1906, it was changed to a ten-second blast followed by ten seconds of silence.
In 1917, the north pier received a new concrete superstructure requiring all 1,040 linear feet of the elevated walkway to be taken down and re-erected. On May 11, 1917 the characteristic of both the breakwater light and the pierhead light was changed to flashing red, and the structures housing the lights were painted red instead of white. In 1925, the pierhead fog signal was changed to an air diaphone in 1925, and the light was electrified.
Lillian Bennett moved into the keepers’ dwelling next to Kenosha Lighthouse in 1915, when her father, Frederick M. Bennett, became the station’s first assistant keeper, and she later shared her memories of life on Simmons Island:
Charles Young lived downstairs in the keeper’s dwelling. He was the keeper and my father was the assistant. The house was nice. It was kept just beautiful. The brass doorknobs were polished – everything had to be just so. The inspector came twice a year and inspected the house. The basement floor was painted. We didn’t have a furnace then – there were coal stoves. We had a big range upstairs in our kitchen – a wood and coal burner.Lillian returned to her lighthouse home in September 1994 to be part of the ceremonies celebrating the rededication of the lighthouse, after it had been refurbished and outfitted with a new lantern room.
We didn’t have any electric lights when we moved there. I must have been about, oh, ten years old when they put in electric lights. So it was about 1918 when they put in the lights in – about the time of the war. When there were storms, my dad would go out to the red pierhead lighthouse … the Coast Guard had a little lookout on the pier … they would call after my dad got out to the lighthouse to start the foghorn … the Coast Guard would call us to say he got here okay, so my mother wouldn’t worry about him.
They also used the old lighthouse in the bad weather to put up the weather flags …when there was a storm warning. The light was gone by that time. They used a tripod to put the flags on. We used to go up the old lighthouse and when you got almost to the top, there was a landing … and there was a little cupboard up there … and we used to have a play house up there.
The elevated walkway and fog signal structure disappeared from the north pier long ago, but the red cylindrical tower continues to serve as the primary light at Kenosha. A cylindrical D-9 tower was installed on the southern end of the breakwater in the 1960s.
In June 2008, Kenosha Pierhead Lighthouse, deemed excess by the Coast Guard, was offered at no cost to eligible entities, including federal, state and local agencies, non-profit corporations, educational agencies, or community development organizations. After no qualified group stepped forward to assume responsibility for the lighthouse, it was placed on the General Services Administration auction website starting on October 18, 2010. Since the fifty-foot-tall cylindrical tower offers no living space and a potential owner would have to obtain a lease from the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, which owns the pier, it is not too surprising that the minimum bid of $10,000 was not received before the auction closed on December 2.
A second auction for Kenosha Pierhead Lighthouse started on May 25, 2011 with a starting bid of $5,000. A bid for this amount was placed on June 17, and the auction closed on July 15 with a winning bid of $17,000. Five bidders participated in the auction, and the winner of the auction was John Burhani, a local artist. Burhani, who fished off the pier as a kid and learned to sail in Kenosha Harbor, felt the lighthouse would be the perfect space for his studio. After the interior of the tower was renovated during the spring of 2012, the lighthouse was opened on select days so the public can view Burhan’s work, which features marine scenes and sailboats. John Burhani passed away in 2015 at the age of forty-nine, following a courageous battle with non-Hodgkins lymphoma.