In 1913, the original lighthouse was torn down and replaced by a new square wooden dwelling, surmounted by an iron lantern, built 152 meters to the east.
William Faulkner became keeper of the Burntcoat Head Lighthouse on August 1, 1874, replacing the light's first keeper, Nathan Smith who retired. Six different Faulkners would serve at the lighthouse, with the final one being Ervin Faulkner (1949-1960).
The 1913 Burntcoat Lighthouse was purposely burned down in 1972 and replaced with a skeleton mast, then discontinued altogether a few years later. In 1992 a community group built a replica of the 1913 light which opened in 1995.
Today the lighthouse and grounds are part of Burntcoat Head Park, which is open to the public. At low tide one can walk onto the mud flats for a spectacular view which is well worth the price of getting ones shoes and pants muddy.