Grande Anse did have an authentic lighthouse at one time as The George Eddy Company of Bathurst completed a seventeen-foot-tall wooden tower there in 1914 under a contract for $800. The 1917 edition of The St. Lawrence Pilot notes that Grande Anse had a population of 700 to 800 inhabitants, and that a boat harbour had been formed by constructing a breakwater in the bay. At that time, a 297-foot-long groin was being built to protect the boat harbour from the eastward.
The 1914 Grande Anse Lighthouse, a square wooden tower with sloping sides and equipped with a sixth-order lens, was originally situated just east of the inner end of the western breakwater at the boat harbour.
Onesime P. Landry served as the keeper of the light from 1915 until at least 1923.
The fate of the 1914 Grande Anse Lighthouse is not known at this time.
The faux lighthouse at Grande Anse was painted in the colours of the Acadian flag in 2001. Before that time, it was white with a red lantern and red trim, and a couple of large red question marks on its sides indicated the purpose of the structure.